Description
Prominent Germantown Commercial corner, ZONING leaves options! Successful STR neighbor! Close to Louisville's most beloved restaurants, coffee shops, and local hotspots, 1139 E St. Catherine Street, combined with 1014 & 1016 Schiller Avenue, presents an investment opportunity in one of the city's strongest rental corridors. Held by the same owner for over 20 years, this 1900 3 plex blends historic charm with proven performance. With three separately metered units, in-unit laundry in every unit, and a newer roof plus HVAC updates in the longest-standing apartment, this property is both stable and packed with value-add upside. Two updated units within the past 10yrs ($935 & $975), well below today's Germantown market rates, and one long-term tenant of 20 years sits at $675/month At stabilization, projected market rents of $1,200-$1,350 per unit and support estimated property values between $440,000 and $500,000+, depending on finishes and cap rate targets. With strong walkability, excellent visibility, and flexible use potential including mixed-use, short-term rentals, or redevelopment into modern urban row-style townhomes, this property is primed for growth and opportunity. Listed at $380,000, this is one of the rare Germantown multifamily assets offering both current cash flow and meaningful future upside. Full Rent Roll and Pro Forma Financials available upon request.
-
5BEDS
-
0.09ACRES
-
0BATHS
-
01/2 BATHS
-
2,311SQFT
-
$151$/SQFT
School Ratings & Info
Description
Prominent Germantown Commercial corner, ZONING leaves options! Successful STR neighbor! Close to Louisville's most beloved restaurants, coffee shops, and local hotspots, 1139 E St. Catherine Street, combined with 1014 & 1016 Schiller Avenue, presents an investment opportunity in one of the city's strongest rental corridors. Held by the same owner for over 20 years, this 1900 3 plex blends historic charm with proven performance. With three separately metered units, in-unit laundry in every unit, and a newer roof plus HVAC updates in the longest-standing apartment, this property is both stable and packed with value-add upside. Two updated units within the past 10yrs ($935 & $975), well below today's Germantown market rates, and one long-term tenant of 20 years sits at $675/month At stabilization, projected market rents of $1,200-$1,350 per unit and support estimated property values between $440,000 and $500,000+, depending on finishes and cap rate targets. With strong walkability, excellent visibility, and flexible use potential including mixed-use, short-term rentals, or redevelopment into modern urban row-style townhomes, this property is primed for growth and opportunity. Listed at $380,000, this is one of the rare Germantown multifamily assets offering both current cash flow and meaningful future upside. Full Rent Roll and Pro Forma Financials available upon request.
Related Properties
© 2025 Metro Search Inc. All rights reserved. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program of Metro Search, Inc. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than The Yenshaw Team | Century 21 Advantage Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo or the Internet Data Exchange thumbnail logo and detailed information about each listing includes the name of the listing broker. Data last updated: 2025-12-11T12:58:01.637.
Listing provided courtesy of EXP Realty LLC: (888) 624-6448.
© 2025 Metro Search, Inc. All rights reserved.